As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Gerry Potratz, who writes Laundry FAQs, uses Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Laundry Detergent in the Rain Water scent in his own laundry room. He finds it very effective on stains, he needs only a small amount per load, and his family members with fragrance sensitivity have not been bothered by it. If someone in your house has eczema or reacts to fragrance, start instead with a fragrance-free detergent that carries the National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance, such as Tide Free & Gentle or all free clear.
Last updated: November 18, 2026.
How this list was put together: Gerry uses Mrs. Meyer’s himself. The other picks are researched, not tested. They come from manufacturer pages, the National Eczema Association’s Seal of Acceptance listings, EPA Safer Choice certifications, and government and university sources, all linked at the end. Prices change often, so this guide doesn’t list them.

Gerry’s pick: Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Laundry Detergent, Rain Water
Gerry’s bottle is the 64 fl oz Rain Water. Here is what he says about it, in his own words:
For laundry I use Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day laundry detergent. I have found it is very effective on stains and has a pleasant fresh fragrance. I have family members that have fragrance sensitivity issues and this product doesn’t bother them.
The amount of Mrs. Meyer’s detergent required is small compared to other products. A positive is the elimination of the need for dryer sheets, which can cause problems in dryer ventilation in my experience.
Gerry Potratz, on the detergent in his own laundry room
What the maker says about it: Mrs. Meyer’s describes the formula as made with dirt- and stain-fighting enzymes, low sudsing, and safe for HE top-loading and front-loading machines as well as conventional washers. Its listed ingredients include protease, amylase, pectinase and mannanase enzyme blends. The company says it is made without phosphates, parabens, phthalates, optical brighteners and artificial colors (Mrs. Meyer’s product page).
One thing to be clear about: Rain Water is a scented detergent, not a fragrance-free one. The ingredient list includes fragrance and says it contains fragrance allergens. Gerry’s point is that the fragrance-sensitive members of his family have not been bothered by it. That is one household’s experience. Anyone with a diagnosed fragrance allergy or eczema should look at the fragrance-free picks below first.
About dryer sheets: Gerry counts not needing dryer sheets as a plus of Mrs. Meyer’s, because in his experience dryer sheets can cause problems with dryer ventilation. There is a documented reason to keep an eye on this. GE Appliances advises that if you use a fabric softener or anti-static conditioner, you should wash the lint filter periodically in warm, soapy water to remove the residue from the screen (GE Appliances). And the U.S. Fire Administration reports that failure to clean was the leading factor in home clothes dryer fires from 2018 to 2020, at 31 percent (USFA). For more on the trade-offs, see dryer balls vs. dryer sheets.
See Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Rain Water (64 fl oz, 2-pack) on Amazon
Quick comparison
| Need | Pick | Why it made the list | Scent |
|---|---|---|---|
| Everyday use (Gerry’s pick) | Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day, Rain Water | Used in Gerry’s home; maker lists enzymes and HE compatibility | Scented |
| Sensitive skin | Tide Free & Gentle | NEA Seal of Acceptance and NPF Seal of Recognition, per P&G | Free of perfumes and dyes |
| Sensitive skin, alternative | all free clear | Listed in the NEA Seal of Acceptance directory | Free of perfumes and dyes |
| Eco-minded | Seventh Generation Free & Clear | EPA Safer Choice certified; USDA Certified Biobased | Fragrance free |
| Eco and septic | ECOS Free & Clear | EPA Safer Choice certified, per ECOS | No added fragrance |
| HE washer, cold water | Tide Original liquid | HE detergent sold as “boosted clean even in cold water” | Scented |
| Budget | Arm & Hammer Clean Burst | Marketed by its maker as a value detergent | Scented |
| Pods | Tide PODS Original | Pre-measured, HE compatible | Scented |
| Sheets | Earth Breeze Fragrance-Free | Pre-measured sheets, no liquid to pour | Fragrance free |
Best for sensitive skin: Tide Free & Gentle
If skin irritation is the main worry, start with a detergent that is free of perfumes and dyes and has been reviewed for sensitive skin. Tide says its Free & Gentle liquid has the National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance and the National Psoriasis Foundation Seal of Recognition (Tide, P&G). The NEA says its Seal is not an endorsement. It means the maker submitted the formula and test results and met the Seal criteria. The NEA also notes that eczema differs from person to person, so trying the product is still the real test (NEA).
See Tide Free & Gentle liquid on Amazon
Alternative: all free clear
all free clear products appear in the NEA Seal of Acceptance directory. The NEA listing for all free clear The Original Concentrated says it is free of perfumes and dyes, works in cold water, is compatible with HE machines, and is EPA Safer Choice certified (NEA listing). The exact bottle on Amazon may be a different all free clear formula, so check the label for the seal you want.
See all free clear liquid on Amazon
Best eco-minded pick: Seventh Generation Free & Clear
EPA Safer Choice is a federal label for cleaning products whose ingredients meet the EPA’s safer-chemistry standard. Seventh Generation lists its Free & Clear liquid as EPA Safer Choice certified and as a USDA Certified Biobased product. The company says it has no dyes, optical brighteners or fragrances and works in HE and standard machines at all water temperatures (Seventh Generation).
See Seventh Generation Free & Clear on Amazon
Alternative: ECOS Free & Clear
ECOS publishes its Safer Choice-certified products with full ingredient lists. Its Free & Clear liquid lists water, three plant-derived surfactants and two preservatives (ECOS). We looked at the brand in more detail in is ECOS laundry detergent good?. If you are on a septic system, see is all laundry detergent safe for septic systems? first. Dose and the number of loads per day matter as much as the brand.
See ECOS Free & Clear on Amazon
Best for HE washers and cold water: Tide Original liquid
Most newer washers are high-efficiency (HE) models, which use less water and need a low-sudsing detergent made for them. ENERGY STAR notes that the “HE” mark on detergent is meant to match the detergent to HE washer types. It is not an energy rating (ENERGY STAR). Tide sells its Original liquid as an HE detergent with “boosted clean even in cold water.”
Cold washes are worth trying. A University of Florida Extension publication, citing the U.S. Department of Energy, says about 90 percent of the energy used to wash clothes goes to heating the water (UF/IFAS Extension). The American Cleaning Institute says everyday stains should come out in cold water. It suggests the warmest setting safe for the fabric for very dirty clothes or tough stains (ACI).
See Tide Original liquid on Amazon
Best budget pick: Arm & Hammer Clean Burst
Church & Dwight, which makes Arm & Hammer, has described its Arm & Hammer laundry detergents in its annual report as value products, priced at a discount from the brands it identifies as market leaders (2016 Form 10-K). The big jugs are HE compatible, according to the product listing. Prices vary by store and week, so compare the cost per load printed on the shelf tag.
See Arm & Hammer Clean Burst on Amazon
Pods and sheets
Pods and sheets take measuring out of the job. That helps, because overdosing is one of the most common laundry mistakes. Our detergent dosage calculator can help if you use liquid.
Pods: Tide PODS Original
Tide PODS are pre-measured and HE compatible, according to the listing. For more on using them, see can you use Tide Pods in a washer?. Safety: the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says to keep laundry packets in their original container, out of a child’s sight and reach, and not to let children handle them (CPSC).
See Tide PODS Original on Amazon
Sheets: Earth Breeze Fragrance-Free
Detergent sheets are thin, pre-measured strips that dissolve in the wash, with no jug to pour or recycle. Earth Breeze sells a Fragrance-Free version. If you are curious how sheets are made, see how are laundry detergent sheets made?.
See Earth Breeze Fragrance-Free sheets on Amazon
How to choose a laundry detergent
- Skin and scent first. If anyone in the house has eczema, allergies or fragrance sensitivity, start with a fragrance-free, dye-free detergent that has the NEA Seal. Wash new clothes before wearing them.
- Match the washer. HE machines need HE detergent. Look for the HE symbol on the label.
- Think about water temperature. Cold water saves the most energy and handles everyday soil. Use warmer water, if the care label allows, for heavy soil and greasy stains.
- Pick a form you will dose correctly. Liquid is good for pretreating stains. Pods and sheets are pre-measured. Powder has its own trade-offs, covered in powder vs. liquid laundry detergent.
- Look for enzymes if you fight food and body-soil stains. Protease, amylase and similar enzymes break down protein and starch stains. Many detergents list them, including Mrs. Meyer’s.
- Check certifications rather than buzzwords. “Natural” and “eco” are marketing words. EPA Safer Choice and the NEA Seal are programs with published criteria.
- Comparing a brand you already own? See our looks at Persil and ECOS.
For tough stains, a detergent alone is often not enough. See our guide to the best stain remover for clothes, including the Shout spray Gerry uses alongside Mrs. Meyer’s.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best laundry detergent?
There is no single best detergent for every home. Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day is the one Gerry uses; he finds it very effective on stains and needs only a small amount per load. For sensitive skin, a fragrance-free detergent with the National Eczema Association Seal, such as Tide Free & Gentle or all free clear, is the safer starting point.
Is Mrs. Meyer’s laundry detergent fragrance-free?
No. The Rain Water version is scented, and its ingredient list includes fragrance and says it contains fragrance allergens. Gerry’s fragrance-sensitive family members have not been bothered by it, but people with fragrance allergies or eczema should choose a fragrance-free detergent.
What laundry detergent is best for sensitive skin?
Look for a detergent free of perfumes and dyes with the National Eczema Association Seal of Acceptance. Tide Free & Gentle and all free clear products are examples. Skin reactions are individual, so the NEA still recommends trying a product to see how it works for you.
Do I need HE detergent?
If you have a high-efficiency washer, yes. HE machines use less water and need a low-sudsing detergent. Look for the HE symbol on the label. Most major detergents, including the ones in this guide, are sold in HE versions.
Does laundry detergent work in cold water?
Yes. The American Cleaning Institute says everyday stains should come out in cold water. Washing cold also saves energy, because about 90 percent of washing energy goes to heating water. Use the warmest water safe for the fabric for heavy soil or tough stains.
Are pods better than liquid detergent?
Pods are pre-measured, which prevents overdosing, but you cannot use them to pretreat a stain. Liquid lets you adjust the dose and rub a little into a spot. If you have small children, store pods in their original container out of sight and reach, as the CPSC advises.
Sources
- Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day: Rain Water Laundry Detergent (product page and ingredient list)
- Tide: Caring for sensitive skin (Free & Gentle, NEA and NPF seals)
- P&G Science Behind: Free & Gentle products recognized by NEA and NPF
- National Eczema Association: Seal of Acceptance program and FAQ
- National Eczema Association: all free clear The Original Concentrated (Seal of Acceptance listing)
- Seventh Generation: Liquid Laundry Detergent, Free & Clear
- ECOS: EPA Safer Choice certified products and ingredient lists
- ENERGY STAR: Consumer Messaging Guide for certified appliances (clothes washers, HE label)
- University of Florida IFAS Extension: Energy Efficient Homes, Laundry Area (citing the U.S. Department of Energy)
- American Cleaning Institute: Stain Removal Guide
- Church & Dwight Form 10-K for 2016 (SEC)
- U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission: Poison Prevention (laundry packets)
- GE Appliances: Dryer, how to clean the lint filter
- U.S. Fire Administration: Appliance and electrical fire safety