As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
For a few delicate items washed by hand, a small amount of mild dishwashing liquid can stand in for laundry detergent; the American Cleaning Institute says some dish liquids can be used for handwashing delicate fabrics. For a machine load, there is no good substitute. The ACI says dishwashing liquid should not go in an automatic washer, GE Appliances says homemade detergent has not been tested and does not recommend it in high-efficiency washers, and Tide says baking soda and vinegar cannot replace a detergent. If you run out, a short wait for detergent is usually better than a risky stand-in.
Last updated: November 14, 2026.
Below: what works for hand washing, what to avoid in a washing machine, how baking soda, vinegar and homemade mixes compare, and what to do if you are out of detergent. Related guides: can you use Dawn as laundry detergent, can you use baking soda for laundry detergent, can you use shampoo for laundry detergent and is it cheaper to make your own laundry detergent.
Common substitutes compared
| Substitute | Hand washing | Washing machine | What the sources say |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mild dishwashing liquid | A small amount, for delicates | No | ACI: some can be used for handwashing delicate fabrics; do not use in automatic washers |
| Baking soda | As a booster only | As a booster only | Tide: less efficient than detergent and cannot substitute for one |
| White vinegar | As a booster only | Use sparingly | Tide: cannot substitute for detergent; Whirlpool says vinegar can damage washer components over time |
| Homemade detergent | Not tested | Not in HE washers | GE does not recommend it in high-efficiency washers because it has not been tested |
| Bar soap | For pretreating stains | No | ACI: soap reacts with hard-water minerals to form curd that can leave a white powder and stiff fabric |
Best option for hand washing
If you need to wash a few items in the sink:
- Use a small amount of mild dishwashing liquid or shampoo in a basin of water. The ACI notes some dish liquids can be used for handwashing delicate fabrics.
- Swish and gently squeeze; don’t wring delicate fabrics.
- Rinse several times until no suds remain.
- Lay flat or hang to dry.
For details on specific stand-ins, see shampoo, body wash and Dawn.
What to avoid in a washing machine
- Dishwashing liquid. The ACI’s laundry basics guide says plainly: do not use it in automatic washers.
- Homemade detergent in an HE washer. GE says homemade laundry detergent has not been tested and it does not recommend using it in high-efficiency washers. See does homemade laundry detergent ruin washers.
- Soap in hard water. The ACI explains that hard water contains calcium and magnesium, which react with soap to form a curd. That curd uses up some of the soap’s cleaning power and can show up on clothes as a white powder, make fabrics feel stiff and stick to the inside of the washer.
Baking soda and vinegar
Baking soda and vinegar are popular, but Tide, which makes detergent, says they are considerably less efficient than laundry detergent and cannot substitute for it. Tide also notes:
- Used together in the same wash, baking soda and vinegar neutralize each other, canceling out their effects.
- Adding either one alongside detergent can lower cleaning performance, because detergents are made to work at a specific pH.
- Extreme use can affect coatings on some washer parts.
Whirlpool separately says vinegar can damage washing machine components over time and does not recommend it for cleaning the washer, while baking soda is generally safe for deodorizing the machine. Keep both as occasional helpers for small stains and odors, not as your detergent.
Homemade detergent
Beyond GE’s warning about HE washers, the ACI raises a few general points about homemade cleaners:
- Some homemade mixtures may leave a residue that attracts new soil, so cleaning has to be done more often.
- Because homemade mixtures often need more “elbow grease,” people tend to use more of them.
- Poison control centers have extensive data on commercial products but may struggle with accidental exposures to homemade mixtures without the formula.
For the cost side, see is it cheaper to make your own laundry detergent.
If you’ve run out of detergent
- Wait if you can. Most loads can sit in the hamper for a day.
- Hand wash the essentials in the sink with a little mild soap and rinse well.
- Don’t double up later. Using more than the recommended amount of detergent can leave residue and lead to mildew odors, according to Whirlpool.
- Keep a backup. Detergent sheets or a small bottle take little space.
Frequently asked questions
Can I use dish soap in my washing machine?
No. The American Cleaning Institute says dishwashing liquids should not be used in automatic washers. Use dish soap only for hand washing delicate items.
Can I wash clothes with just water?
None of the sources we reviewed treat plain water as a replacement for detergent. Tide notes that even when additives loosen soils, removing stains takes detergent action.
Can baking soda replace laundry detergent?
Not fully. Tide says baking soda and vinegar can help with small stains and odors but cannot substitute for detergent. See can you use baking soda for laundry detergent.
Is homemade detergent safe for HE washers?
GE does not recommend it, because homemade detergent has not been tested in high-efficiency washers. Check your own washer’s manual.
Sources
- American Cleaning Institute, Laundry Basics
- American Cleaning Institute, DIY or Homemade Cleaners
- GE Appliances, High Efficiency Washers and Detergent
- Tide, Washing Clothes with Baking Soda and Vinegar
- Whirlpool, Why Does My Washing Machine Smell Like Mildew?
Resource Links
- https://www.cleaninginstitute.org/cleaning-tips/clothes/laundry-basics
- https://www.cleaninginstitute.org/understanding-products/diy-or-homemade-cleaners
- https://products.geappliances.com/appliance/gea-support-search-content?contentId=16916
- https://tide.com/en-us/how-to-wash-clothes/how-to-do-laundry/baking-soda-vinegar-laundry
- https://www.whirlpool.com/blog/washers-and-dryers/washer-smells-like-mildew.html